Right-of-entry dispute leads Court to examine whether training is work
The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia recently dealt with a right-of-entry dispute following two union officials holding entry permits seeking to enter a training centre to hold discussions with apprentices.
When can right of entry be exercised?
The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) establishes a right for a union official holding an entry permit issued under the FW Act to enter premises for the purpose of holding discussions.
To exercise this right at a particular premises, the permit-holder must have the subjective purpose of holding discussions with employees who:
- perform work on the premises;
- are entitled to be represented by the permit-holder’s union; and
- wish to participate in those discussions.
The right is limited, in that:
- it may only be exercised during working hours;
- any discussions with employees may only occur during meal and rest breaks;
- the permit-holder must comply with an occupier’s reasonable request to comply with a work health and safety requirement;
- discussions must occur at an agreed location, or otherwise in the meal room or area;
- the permit-holder must comply with a reasonable request by the occupier to take a particular route to the discussion area; and
- the permit-holder is prohibited from intentionally hindering or obstructing any person or otherwise acting in an improper manner while exercising the entry right.
In ECA Training Pty Limited v Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia (2026), the Court had to determine whether the right of entry existed when, at the time the right was exercised, there weren’t any employees on the premise at work who were entitled to be represented by the permit-holder’s union and/or who wished to engage in discussions with the permit-holder.
The Court held that, as long as the permit-holder has, at the time of entry, the subjective purpose described above, it does not matter that in fact there are no employees at the premises at that time who fall within the requisite cohort (i.e. able to join the union, performing work and wanting to talk to the official). It doesn’t matter that the permit-holder ends up participating in discussions with employees who do not fall within that class, provided they do so voluntarily.
When is training ‘work’?
The Court also had to determine whether apprentices performed work when attending formal training sessions at a site separate from their employer’s usual workplace.
The Court observed that the concept of ‘work’ in the context of working hours is not confined to periods spent undertaking particular types of duties or tasks; rather it refers to all the time during which the employee is required to attend to their employment obligations and is available to perform work in accordance with the lawful and reasonable instructions of their employer. Wages are payable for hours of work performed. An employee performs work when they are performing service that they are obliged to provide in accordance with their contract of employment. Therefore, given formal training was part of the apprentices’ employment contracts, they were at work when they attended that formal training.
Tasking carpenter with work outside skillset results in tragic fall from height
A commercial construction company was fined $150,000 after the unsafe removal of a tree at its Carrum Downs site left a carpenter a paraplegic following a fall from height ...
Get the latest employment law news, legal updates, case law and practical advice from our experts sent straight to your inbox every week.
